Overall assessment of the specific circumstances
There are other factors as well, beyond those provided in the Act, and these should also be taken into consideration when determining whether a person is an employee or an independent contractor. All factors should be included in an overall assessment of the true nature of the relationship.
- Does the person work primarily for one employer or client?
- Is their affiliation relatively stable?
- Can the affiliation be terminated with a given notice period?
- Is the undertaking (employer) liable for the work performance?
- Does the undertaking (employer) provide the tools, equipment or aids necessary to perform the work?
If you can answer all of these questions with ‘yes’, it is indication that the person is an employee.
Which of these factors are given the most weight and significance may vary from case to case. As no two cases are the same, an individual and specific assessment must be made of the person’s affiliation in each case.
The list above is not exhaustive, and also other factors may be taken into consideration, such as whether the work is associated with health and safety risks that necessitates protection as an employee.
In addition, while the assessment may be accurate today, it may not necessarily be accurate after some time. Changes in affiliation may affect the assessment.
The Working Environment Act distinguishes between employees and independent contractors. These categories are mutually exclusive. This means one person cannot simultaneously be both an employee and an independent contractor in a single affiliation.
In summary, the difference between an employee and an independent contractor is as follows:
- An employee performs work for, and is subordinate to, someone else.
- An independent contractor performs work for him/herself and is clearly independent.
The Working Environment Act consistently uses the term independent contractor (“selvstendig oppdragstaker”) about persons who perform independent contract work. This term includes any person who (without having employees of their own) perform work by taking on assignments from an undertaking without being an employee.
It is unfavourable for both parties when it is unclear whether a person should be considered an employee or an independent contractor. The Working Environment Act therefore includes a requirement that clients must be able to prove that the independent contractor is, in fact, an independent contractor.
The person shall be considered to be an employee unless the client shows it to be “highly probable” that an independent contractual relationship exists.
This standard was implemented on 01 January 2024, and the motivation behind the amendment is to reduce grey areas for workers in terms of their affiliation. A correct classification is significant for the person’s rights under the law, see below.
The amendment implemented on 01 January 2024 did not change the right of undertakings to use independent contractors, and it also did not change the definition of who is considered an employee and who is considered an independent contractor.
The contract regulating the affiliation plays an important role as evidence in a determination of whether a person is an employee or an independent contractor.
Nevertheless, if the contract does not accurately reflect the true nature of the contractual relationship, it will not have much relevance as evidence. The actual circumstances are the determining factor. The contract may be titled “Contract for independent contractors”, but this is not a determining factor in whether or not the person is considered to be an employee or an independent contractor.
Employment contract requirements
Employees who are in a contractual relationship as an employee, must be provided with a written employment contract. The Working Environment Act includes requirements for the contents of an employment contract.